Stage 2 review notes and current ident contact sheet
pauljd/davidson-ci: Davidson CI / quality (push) Failing after 1m55s
pauljd/davidson-ci: Davidson CI / ai-review (push) Failing after 1m26s

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
2026-11-03 16:26:19 +00:00
co-authored by Claude Opus 5.5
parent ef37d8b002
commit 0d4b7c47a0
2 changed files with 13 additions and 0 deletions
@@ -28,3 +28,16 @@ Nothing has been changed. Where each identity lives today:
| Rewind (604) | Rewind logo with the arrows beside the word (refine-feedback-04.py) | res/raw/ident_604.mp4, 1280x720, 30 fps, 7.0 s, 252 KB | depth-native/world/rewind (planes: sky, stars, grid, cabinet, scanlines) |
Budgets to keep: 7-second idents at 1280x720, silent, a few hundred KB each; the ident holds its last frame until the next programme's first frame (IDENT_HOLD_MS), so each refined ident needs a clean final frame. Approach once approved: copy each source to a new versioned folder (originals untouched), make a before-and-after still and a short preview clip for each channel, and render production idents only after Paul approves the previews. The two further redesign briefs are still to come.
## Stage 2 review notes (3 November 2026, from the idents in the app)
Contact sheet: docs/briefs/stage2-current-idents.png (left: the settled logo at 5 seconds; right: the last frame, which is what the screen holds while the next programme loads).
**Shared finding:** all three idents end mid-fade. The last frame is dim, and on Riot the static layer and a ghost of the logo sit over the word; on VHS the right-hand reel shows through the label. That's the frame held during transitions, so the first fix for all three is a clean, fully lit final frame (the settled logo), with the fade left to the app's overlay.
**Riot, proposed 5%:** ORBIT larger and white with a thin dark edge (it's tiny at the top-left of the TV today); RIOT given a thin black cut-out outline and a small offset print shadow in pink; remove the small white crown glyph by the TV corner and the lime tick marks (one small element out, nothing added); keep bolt, burst, checkerboard, torn paper, city. Motion: the same entrance, ending on the settled frame rather than static.
**VHS, proposed 5%:** ORBIT aligned to the left edge of VHS and slightly larger; right-hand label lines tidied into an even column; one small angled "RETURN BY MONDAY" sticker on the label's corner; very faint paper grain on the label only. Motion: a short tracking wobble and a two-frame mechanical settle into a crisp, fully lit final frame with no reel showing through.
**Rewind, proposed 5%:** even spacing between REWIND and the two arrows inside the pink pill; a lighter rim on the TV so it separates from the purple; ORBIT and the planet aligned to the pill's left edge with the ring in the same pink. Motion: a quick right-to-left scan streak, like rewinding, before it settles on a clean final frame. No VHS-style distortion.
**Process once approved:** copies in new versioned folders (originals untouched), a before-and-after still and a short preview clip per channel at the current 1280x720, 7 s, a few hundred KB; production idents only after Paul approves the previews. Suggested first batch: Riot.
Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 1.1 MiB