Docs: language counts in localization-parity and gaps match the catalogs

localization-parity.md: the key-language table has 13 rows, so its
heading says thirteen. 22 catalog rows give counts taken on main at
ee60c51fd9. A row is a non-comment line of crates/ui-egui/src/i18n/
<code>.tsv with three tab-separated columns and a non-empty source and
translation, as catalog::parse_entries reads it; `@msg` and
`@msgplural` are rows with that first column. Missing-string counts
come from `cargo xtask i18n-report` on the same commit and include the
strings it lists under "every language" (1 menu string, 1 `tl!`
literal, 3 undo labels and 15 messages). Notes naming pull requests
that would translate the missing messages are removed with the old
counts; #7434, still open, was one of them. The measurement note says
the 4,020 French reference applies to the percentages only.

- zh-hans 9,625 rows, 3,735 `@msg`, 51 `@msgplural`; 237 messages missing
- fr 9,770, 3,731, 51; 246 messages
- pt-br 9,868, 3,744, 51; 236 messages
- ja 9,477, 3,738, 51; 237 messages
- de 9,371, 3,742, 51; 236 messages
- vi 7,654, 1,968, 51; 1,974 messages
- zh-hant 9,428, 3,735, 51; 237 messages
- it 9,415, 3,740, 51; 237 messages
- nl 9,848, 3,747, 51; 235 messages
- da 9,928, 3,838, 51; 118 messages
- ru 9,866, 3,742, 51; 242 messages, 72 menu strings, 34 `tl!`
  literals, 16 undo labels
- uk 9,412, 3,738, 51
- hu 9,774, 3,743, 51; 236 messages, 73 menu strings, 38 `tl!`
  strings, 16 undo labels, 45 swatch names
- pl 9,650, 3,736, 51; 242 messages, 73 menu strings, 39 `tl!`
  literals, 16 undo labels, 45 swatch names
- fi 8,074, 1,975, 51; 1,974 messages
- cs 9,761, 3,742, 51; 222 Czech messages plus 15 in every language
- bs 7,227, 1,205, 47; 113 menu strings, 66 `tl!` literals, 30 undo
  labels
- sv 9,498, 3,311, 51; 647 messages, 31 menu strings, 14 `tl!`
  literals, 6 undo labels
- bg 7,133, 1,111, 47; 76 menu strings, 48 `tl!` literals, 16 undo
  labels, 45 swatch names
- el 8,003, 1,972, 51; 1,974 messages
- tr 9,784, 3,746, 51; 235 messages, 79 menu strings, 39 `tl!`
  literals, 16 undo labels
- ca 8,036, 1,956, 51; 1,990 messages

The es, hi, id, ka, ko and gu rows and the catalog total under the
second table are left as they are, since open pull requests change
those lines or add a row next to them.

gaps.md: G16 is titled "Localization: remaining language work", with
the table link updated to the new anchor. Its own Missing list names
Arabic as the only key language without a catalog.
This commit is contained in:
dotCooCoo
2026-11-17 14:41:27 -08:00
parent ee60c51fd9
commit f74c7d5934
2 changed files with 30 additions and 28 deletions
+2 -2
View File
@@ -105,7 +105,7 @@ stage ([ROADMAP.md](../ROADMAP.md)).
| 13 | [G7 Views and windows](#g7-views-and-windows) | 15–25 | no | [ui-parity.md](ui-parity.md) |
| 14 | [G6 Automation and scripting](#g6-automation-and-scripting) | 4–8 | no | [target-app-parity.md](target-app-parity.md) |
| 15 | [G15 Performance budgets and a GPU renderer](#g15-performance-budgets-and-a-gpu-renderer) | 15–25 | budgets only | [hardware-parity.md](hardware-parity.md) |
| 16 | [G16 Localization: the three missing key languages](#g16-localization-the-three-missing-key-languages) | 50–85 | no | [localization-parity.md](localization-parity.md) |
| 16 | [G16 Localization: remaining language work](#g16-localization-remaining-language-work) | 50–85 | no | [localization-parity.md](localization-parity.md) |
| 17 | [G17 Ecosystem: third-party plug-ins](#g17-ecosystem-third-party-plug-ins) | 20–45 | no | — |
| 18 | [G18 Generative AI features](#g18-generative-ai-features) | 30–60 | no | — |
| 19 | [G19 Accessibility](#g19-accessibility) | 15–25 | no | [ui-parity.md](ui-parity.md) |
@@ -802,7 +802,7 @@ macOS cursor delivery (#2292) is narrowed to a native host adapter using the exi
Crop and Outline landed in #1173.
- **Estimate:** 15–25 h (the budget run and fixes block beta).
## G16 Localization: the three missing key languages
## G16 Localization: remaining language work
- **Evidence (2026-11-06):** Hindi (`hi`): 7,877-row machine-assisted catalog, zero/one singular plurals, desktop font fallback and optional Devanagari craft-fonts fallback; all 55 translation tests pass; native review and a web font remain; scores and estimates unchanged. See [Hindi notes](localization-hi.md).
+28 -26
View File
@@ -8,9 +8,11 @@ Per-language status of VectorCraft's interface. How the catalogs work and how to
**How it is measured:** rows with a translation in each `crates/ui-egui/src/i18n/<code>.tsv`, counted on
origin/main `01e165af`, except the rows that give a count date: those were counted on the `main` commit named in the row (the rows dated 2026-10-21 on `main` at `cb0a7d9`).
The reference is the French catalog, which was complete when counted: 3,416 interface
The percentages (Spanish's, and the historical score below) use the French catalog on `01e165af` as the reference, which was complete when counted: 3,416 interface
strings (menus, command labels, `tl!` literals: panels, dialogs, tooltips, Preferences) plus 604 `@msg` status and
error messages, 4,020 in all. A language's % is its rows over 4,020 (capped at 100% per part). A missing
error messages, 4,020 in all. A language's % is its rows over 4,020 (capped at 100% per part); today's catalogs are
larger, so the row counts dated 2026-11-17 give no percentage, and the untranslated report's count for a language
includes the strings it lists under "every language". A missing
translation never fails a test or a build: the interface shows the English text until a translator adds the row.
`cargo xtask ci` prints the untranslated report (`cargo xtask i18n-report` alone), which lists per language the
strings missing from each catalog with the `complete_menus` flag and the messages missing from each language in
@@ -24,26 +26,26 @@ Chinese by `imachus`). Georgian and the original Gujarati catalog are recorded a
> **Gujarati status (2026-11-14, #6613):** 4,673 catalog rows: the original 4,286 remain unchanged; all 387 additions are contributor-reviewed and approved, with 11 wording corrections. Status/error messages remain partial, and the pinned CI/release fonts and web startup list contain no Gujarati face; web selection stays unavailable until a Gujarati interface face is bundled. Scores and estimates unchanged.
## The twelve key languages
## The thirteen key languages
| Language | Code | UI strings translated | Dialogs / tooltips / messages | Script support | Native review | Status | To `full` (h) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| English | `en` | source, 100% | all | Latin | — | full | — |
| Simplified Chinese (Mandarin) | `zh-hans` | 5,102 rows, 791 of them `@msg` (counted 2026-10-21): menus, `tl!` literals and messages complete when counted | all (3,554 `@msg` and 48 `@msgplural` rows, counted 2026-11-13: the untranslated report lists 55 missing messages for it, which open #7116, #7211, #7330, #7378 and #7405 translate) | CJK UI font from craft-fonts (BIZ UDPGothic) when embedded, else a system font; IME with marked text at the caret; vertical type partial ([type-parity.md](type-parity.md)) | no | full | — (review) |
| Simplified Chinese (Mandarin) | `zh-hans` | 9,625 rows, 3,735 of them `@msg` and 51 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`) | all (the untranslated report lists 237 messages without a row for it) | CJK UI font from craft-fonts (BIZ UDPGothic) when embedded, else a system font; IME with marked text at the caret; vertical type partial ([type-parity.md](type-parity.md)) | no | full | — (review) |
| Spanish | `es` | 4,009 / 4,020 (99.7%) | all (604 messages) | Latin | no | full | — (review) |
| Hindi | `hi` | 8,782 rows (2026-11-13): 3,014 `@msg`, 47 `@msgplural`, 41 `@plural`; the untranslated report on main `f793044f83` (2026-11-14) lists 676 missing rows for it: 608 in its own section and 68 that every checked language lacks | menus, dialogs, tooltips and scanned messages; contributor-approved loanword terminology; agent wording pass | UI and document text shape with HarfRust; installed desktop Devanagari fallback, or a `Deva` craft-fonts face; web font still needed | contributor terminology review; 2026-11-13 wording pass on messages and longer labels, and a word-sense pass on short labels, with a glossary-term test; wider proofread welcome | complete catalog, machine-assisted draft | reported missing rows, native review, layout and web font |
| Gujarati | `gu` | 4,673 rows (2026-11-14): original 4,286 unchanged; all 387 additions contributor-reviewed and approved | menus and dialogs; status/error messages partial | installed Gujarati fonts on desktop; optional `Gujr` craft-fonts fallback; no Gujarati face in the pinned CI/release fonts or web startup list | original catalog reviewed by a native speaker; all 387 later additions approved by the contributor, with 11 wording corrections | contributor-reviewed catalog | remaining messages and a bundled Gujarati web font |
| Arabic | `ar` | 0 | none | document text: bidi layout and Paragraph Direction; interface: no right-to-left layout, no Arabic shaping in egui | no | none | 25–40 |
| French | `fr` | 9,166 rows, 3,436 of them `@msg` and 48 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-13): the untranslated report lists 178 missing messages for it | all | Latin | no | full | — (review) |
| Portuguese | `pt-br` | 9,378 rows, 3,563 of them `@msg` and 48 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-13): the untranslated report lists 55 missing messages for it, which open #7116, #7211, #7330, #7378 and #7405 translate; one/other plurals | all | Latin | contributor is a Brazilian Portuguese speaker; further native review welcome | full | — (review) |
| French | `fr` | 9,770 rows, 3,731 of them `@msg` and 51 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`): the untranslated report lists 246 missing messages for it | all | Latin | no | full | — (review) |
| Portuguese | `pt-br` | 9,868 rows, 3,744 of them `@msg` and 51 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`): the untranslated report lists 236 missing messages for it; one/other plurals | all | Latin | contributor is a Brazilian Portuguese speaker; further native review welcome | full | — (review) |
| Indonesian | `id` | 6,825 rows, 1,036 of them `@msg` and 47 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-14 on `main` at `676f0524cc`): the untranslated report lists 60 missing menu strings, 35 `tl!` literals and 13 undo labels for it; not in `COMPLETE_MESSAGES`, and checked against the same scanned messages it lacks 2,508; one plural form | most dialogs and tooltips; status and error messages partial | Latin | no | full | — (review) |
| Japanese | `ja` | 4,004 / 4,020 (99.6%) | partial (3,562 `@msg` and 49 `@msgplural` rows, counted 2026-11-14: the untranslated report lists 98 messages without a Japanese row, 77 of which every complete-message language lacks; open #7116 and #7211 translate 35 of them) | CJK UI font as above; Japanese IME; vertical type partial; Japanese crop marks and composition settings | no | full | — (review) |
| German | `de` | 3,952 / 4,020 (98%; menus, literals and messages complete when counted) | all (3,563 `@msg` and 48 `@msgplural` rows, counted 2026-11-13: the untranslated report lists 52 missing messages for it, which open #7116, #7211 and #7378 translate) | Latin | contributor-written, not reviewed | full | — (review) |
| Japanese | `ja` | 9,477 rows, 3,738 of them `@msg` and 51 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`) | partial (the untranslated report lists 237 messages without a Japanese row, 15 of which every complete-message language lacks) | CJK UI font as above; Japanese IME; vertical type partial; Japanese crop marks and composition settings | no | full | — (review) |
| German | `de` | 9,371 rows, 3,742 of them `@msg` and 51 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`) | all (the untranslated report lists 236 missing messages for it) | Latin | contributor-written, not reviewed | full | — (review) |
| Korean | `ko` | 4,870 rows (counted 2026-10-21): menus, `tl!` literals and messages complete when counted; one plural form | all (3,438 `@msg` and 48 `@msgplural` rows, counted 2026-11-13: the untranslated report lists 39 missing messages for it) | Hangul from an installed system font on the desktop (Apple SD Gothic Neo, Malgun Gothic, Noto Sans CJK KR…); the web build has no Korean UI font yet (craft-fonts); IME path exists | no (AI-drafted) | full | — (review; web font) |
| Vietnamese | `vi` | 4,886 rows (counted 2026-10-21): menus, `tl!` literals and messages complete when counted; one plural form; 4,046 plain + 18 `@plural` + 28 contextual + 794 `@msg` | dialogs and tooltips all; messages partial (1,750 `@msg` and 49 `@msgplural` rows, counted 2026-11-14: the untranslated report lists 1,875 messages without a Vietnamese row, 53 of which open #7211, #7378, #7405 and #7434 translate) | Latin with Vietnamese diacritics (stacked marks attach in precomposed, decomposed and keyboard forms, #4491; glyph tests pass) | contributor is a Vietnamese speaker; AI-assisted draft, further native review welcome | full | — (review) |
| Vietnamese | `vi` | 7,654 rows, 1,968 of them `@msg` and 51 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`); one plural form | dialogs and tooltips all; messages partial (the untranslated report lists 1,974 messages without a Vietnamese row) | Latin with Vietnamese diacritics (stacked marks attach in precomposed, decomposed and keyboard forms, #4491; glyph tests pass) | contributor is a Vietnamese speaker; AI-assisted draft, further native review welcome | full | — (review) |
**Historical 12-language score: ~82%** (equal weights: 100 + 85 + 100 + 0 + 0 + 100 + 100 + 100 + 100 + 98 + 100 + 100, over 12).
**To `full` for all twelve: ~50–85 h** (historical estimate, not re-scored here). Hindi now has
**To `full` for the twelve in that score: ~50–85 h** (historical estimate, not re-scored here). Hindi now has
a catalog that the tests count as complete, and UI shaping; its remaining work is the rows the
untranslated report lists for it, native review, layout checking and the web font. Arabic still needs its catalog and right-to-left interface. Each new Latin-script catalog is ~4,000 rows; the existing ones were written in a few agent hours each
plus review. Native-speaker review is human work and isn't in the hours.
@@ -52,23 +54,23 @@ plus review. Native-speaker review is human work and isn't in the hours.
| Language | Code | Translated | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Traditional Chinese (Taiwan) | `zh-hant` | 8,820 rows, 3,438 of them `@msg` and 48 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-13): the untranslated report lists 40 missing messages for it; menus, `tl!` literals and messages were complete when counted on 2026-10-21 (80% overall) | partial |
| Italian | `it` | 8,924 rows, 3,560 of them `@msg` and 48 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-13): the untranslated report lists 54 missing messages for it, which open #7116, #7211, #7378 and #7405 translate | full |
| Dutch | `nl` | 3,447 `@msg` and 48 `@msgplural` rows (counted 2026-11-13): in `COMPLETE_MESSAGES`, and the untranslated report lists 41 missing messages for it; one/other plurals | full |
| Danish | `da` | 9,616 rows, 3,702 of them `@msg` and 49 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-15): in `COMPLETE_MESSAGES`, and the untranslated report lists 81 missing messages for it, 46 of them missing in every language; one/other plurals | full |
| Russian | `ru` | 9,259 rows, 3,444 of them `@msg` and 48 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-13): in `COMPLETE_MESSAGES`; the untranslated report lists 46 menu strings, 21 `tl!` literals and 11 undo labels as missing | full |
| Ukrainian | `uk` | 8,802 rows, 3,439 of them `@msg` and 48 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-13); one/few/many plurals | full |
| Hungarian | `hu` | 9,166 rows, 3,444 of them `@msg` and 48 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-13): the untranslated report lists 40 missing messages for it, and lists 47 menu strings, 25 `tl!` strings, 11 undo labels and 45 swatch names without a row; one plural form | full |
| Polish | `pl` | 9,044 rows, 3,439 of them `@msg` and 48 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-13): the untranslated report lists 46 missing messages for it, and 47 menu strings, 26 `tl!` literals, 11 undo labels and 45 swatch names; one/few/many plurals | full; native review pending |
| Finnish | `fi` | 5,318 rows (counted 2026-10-21): menus, `tl!` literals and messages complete when counted; one/other plurals, 797 `@msg` rows | full; AI-assisted, native proofreading pending |
| Czech | `cs` | 9,273 rows, 3,560 of them `@msg` and 48 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-13): the untranslated report lists 2 missing Czech messages, and 54 messages that no language has a row for | catalog complete; render-site gaps reduced; native review pending |
| Bosnian | `bs` | 6,887 rows, 1,144 of them `@msg` and 47 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-14 on `main` at `676f0524cc`): the untranslated report lists 97 missing menu strings, 53 `tl!` literals and 27 undo labels for it; not in `COMPLETE_MESSAGES`, and checked against the same scanned messages it lacks 2,416; one/few/other plurals | full; AI-assisted, native review pending |
| Swedish | `sv` | 8,991 rows, 3,106 of them `@msg` and 48 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-14): the untranslated report lists 518 missing messages for it, and 12 menu strings, 1 `tl!` literal and 3 undo labels; one/other plurals | full; native review welcome |
| Bulgarian | `bg` | 5,245 rows, 763 of them `@msg` (counted 2026-10-21): menus and `tl!` literals complete when counted; its messages are partial | full; AI-drafted, native review pending |
| Greek | `el` | 5,251 rows, 795 of them `@msg` (counted 2026-10-21): menus, `tl!` literals and messages complete when counted | full; native review welcome |
| Traditional Chinese (Taiwan) | `zh-hant` | 9,428 rows, 3,735 of them `@msg` and 51 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`): the untranslated report lists 237 missing messages for it; menus, `tl!` literals and messages were complete when counted on 2026-10-21 (80% overall) | partial |
| Italian | `it` | 9,415 rows, 3,740 of them `@msg` and 51 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`): the untranslated report lists 237 missing messages for it | full |
| Dutch | `nl` | 9,848 rows, 3,747 of them `@msg` and 51 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`): in `COMPLETE_MESSAGES`, and the untranslated report lists 235 missing messages for it; one/other plurals | full |
| Danish | `da` | 9,928 rows, 3,838 of them `@msg` and 51 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`): in `COMPLETE_MESSAGES`, and the untranslated report lists 118 missing messages for it, 15 of them missing in every language; one/other plurals | full |
| Russian | `ru` | 9,866 rows, 3,742 of them `@msg` and 51 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`): in `COMPLETE_MESSAGES`; the untranslated report lists 242 messages, 72 menu strings, 34 `tl!` literals and 16 undo labels as missing | full |
| Ukrainian | `uk` | 9,412 rows, 3,738 of them `@msg` and 51 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`); one/few/many plurals | full |
| Hungarian | `hu` | 9,774 rows, 3,743 of them `@msg` and 51 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`): the untranslated report lists 236 missing messages for it, and lists 73 menu strings, 38 `tl!` strings, 16 undo labels and 45 swatch names without a row; one plural form | full |
| Polish | `pl` | 9,650 rows, 3,736 of them `@msg` and 51 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`): the untranslated report lists 242 missing messages for it, and 73 menu strings, 39 `tl!` literals, 16 undo labels and 45 swatch names; one/few/many plurals | full; native review pending |
| Finnish | `fi` | 8,074 rows, 1,975 of them `@msg` and 51 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`): the untranslated report lists 1,974 missing messages for it; one/other plurals | full; AI-assisted, native proofreading pending |
| Czech | `cs` | 9,761 rows, 3,742 of them `@msg` and 51 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`): the untranslated report lists 222 missing Czech messages, and 15 messages that no checked language has a row for | catalog complete; render-site gaps reduced; native review pending |
| Bosnian | `bs` | 7,227 rows, 1,205 of them `@msg` and 47 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`): the untranslated report lists 113 missing menu strings, 66 `tl!` literals and 30 undo labels for it; not in `COMPLETE_MESSAGES`, so the report does not check its messages; one/few/other plurals | full; AI-assisted, native review pending |
| Swedish | `sv` | 9,498 rows, 3,311 of them `@msg` and 51 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`): the untranslated report lists 647 missing messages for it, and 31 menu strings, 14 `tl!` literals and 6 undo labels; one/other plurals | full; native review welcome |
| Bulgarian | `bg` | 7,133 rows, 1,111 of them `@msg` and 47 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`): the untranslated report lists 76 menu strings, 48 `tl!` literals, 16 undo labels and 45 swatch names for it; its messages are partial | full; AI-drafted, native review pending |
| Greek | `el` | 8,003 rows, 1,972 of them `@msg` and 51 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`): the untranslated report lists 1,974 missing messages for it | full; native review welcome |
| Georgian | `ka` | 5,200 rows (counted 2026-10-21): menus, panels, dialogs, plurals (one count-neutral form) and messages, tested complete; reviewed by a native speaker | full |
| Turkish | `tr` | 9,175 rows, 3,446 of them `@msg` and 48 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-13); 41 messages, 62 menu strings, 26 `tl!` literals, 13 undo labels and the default swatch names still fall back to English | full |
| Catalan | `ca` | 5,626 rows, 881 of them `@msg` (counted 2026-10-28): menus, `tl!` literals and messages complete when counted; one/other plurals; every `ca-*` locale resolves here | full; AI-drafted, native review welcome |
| Turkish | `tr` | 9,784 rows, 3,746 of them `@msg` and 51 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`); 235 messages, 79 menu strings, 39 `tl!` literals, 16 undo labels and the default swatch names still fall back to English | full |
| Catalan | `ca` | 8,036 rows, 1,956 of them `@msg` and 51 `@msgplural` (counted 2026-11-17 on `main` at `ee60c51fd9`): the untranslated report lists 1,990 missing messages for it; one/other plurals; every `ca-*` locale resolves here | full; AI-drafted, native review welcome |
Twenty-seven non-English catalogs in all (registry count, 2026-11-06). Illustrator, as its public documentation lists, ships around two dozen
interface languages (including Polish, Dutch, Turkish, the Nordic languages, Hungarian, and Middle East